I know it’s my thinking, but I still feel anxious
By Chris Finn, BABCP-accredited CBT psychotherapist, life coach and author of A Clear Mind.
“I know I’m overthinking this.”
“I know there’s another way to look at it.”
“I understand why I feel this way—but I still feel it.”
You might be able to explain your difficulty clearly. Perhaps you’ve read about it, talked it through or worked on it in therapy.
Yet when a familiar situation comes around, you still find yourself caught in the same thoughts and feelings.
That can be frustrating. You may even start wondering whether you’re doing something wrong.
I wouldn’t take that frustration as evidence that you haven’t understood, or that you need to try harder.
I’d want to explore what you understand, what still feels difficult and what happens in the moments when you become caught up.
Knowing that something is a thought isn’t the whole conversation
Imagine you’re preparing to speak in a meeting.
The thought appears: “I’m going to make a fool of myself.”
You recognise it. You know it is a prediction, not a fact. You can remember occasions when you spoke perfectly well.
But you still feel tense. You rehearse what you might say, watch for signs that you’re becoming nervous and consider staying quiet.
In that example, recognising the thought is useful information. It isn’t a reason to dismiss the rest of the experience.
We could look at what you fear, what the physical sensations mean to you, how you respond and what you feel you need before you can take part.
There is more to explore than whether you can identify an unhelpful thought.
A thought doesn’t have to disappear before your relationship with it can change
Mindfulness offers one way of approaching this: noticing thoughts as experiences that come and go, rather than automatically treating them as facts or instructions. Its purpose is not to make every thought disappear.
In our work, we might explore the difference between:
“This thought has appeared.”
and:
“I have to resolve this thought before I can get on with my day.”
That second statement gives us something important to look at.
What makes the thought feel like a problem that needs an immediate answer? What do you imagine would happen if you didn’t settle it? Is the search for an answer helping you do what matters, or keeping your attention occupied?
These are questions to explore together—not instructions to ignore something that feels important.
The blindspot may be in what you expect of yourself
Sometimes the thought we notice first isn’t the only thing worth looking at.
You might recognise that you’re worried about making a mistake. But underneath that, there may be an assumption you haven’t considered:
“I shouldn’t feel anxious when I know there is no real danger.”
Now you’re dealing with the original anxiety and judging yourself for still having it.
Or perhaps you believe:
“I need to feel confident before I can speak.”
From that starting point, checking your confidence makes sense. Any nervousness appears to be evidence that you aren’t ready.
I call these psychological blindspots: assumptions that are so familiar they can seem like simple descriptions of reality.
We might explore whether confidence really needs to come first, or whether feeling nervous has come to mean something about you that deserves a closer look.
I’m not interested in persuading you to repeat a more positive sentence. I’m interested in helping you discover whether you have more room to respond than you realised.
This doesn’t mean your concerns are imaginary
Thinking about a difficulty does not make the difficulty unreal.
You might be under an unreasonable amount of pressure. A relationship may need attention. You may face a decision with genuine consequences.
We won’t assume that the answer is always to take your thoughts less seriously.
Part of our work is distinguishing between something that needs action, something that needs space and understanding, and something you are repeatedly trying to settle without moving forward.
Your circumstances belong in that conversation.
Understanding and action can work together
I don’t see a different perspective and practical change as alternatives.
CBT can involve examining beliefs and predictions, approaching situations you have been avoiding, and trying different ways of responding. It is not limited to talking yourself into a different thought.
Returning to the meeting example, we might explore what speaking while nervous would mean to you. We might also agree a manageable opportunity to contribute and look together at what you learn from it.
The conversation informs the action; the experience gives us more to discuss.
Sometimes a new understanding opens up a practical step. Sometimes trying something differently helps you see what a conversation alone hasn’t yet made clear.
We’ll stay interested in what helps you move forward, rather than insist that change must happen in one particular way.
What I mean by a transformative approach
For me, transformative means exploring whether something can change in how you understand yourself or the difficulty—not only finding another way to manage it.
Perhaps you have come to see yourself as someone who can’t cope with uncertainty.
We can certainly discuss ways of handling a difficult decision. But we might also look at how that description of yourself developed and whether it captures the whole picture.
Where have you already acted without certainty? What are you overlooking when you describe yourself that way? What would change if it became a familiar story you could question, rather than a fixed identity?
That is the kind of exploration I mean.
It isn’t a promise of a sudden breakthrough, and you won’t be expected to produce an insight on demand. We’ll begin with your experience and see what becomes useful.
When you’ve already tried therapy
You may have had therapy that helped you understand your patterns without bringing the changes you hoped for.
I’d want to hear about that.
What did you work on? What made sense? What was difficult to use outside the sessions? Was there something you didn’t feel able to say, or something important that the work didn’t address?
You don’t need to dismiss everything you learnt. Equally, you don’t need to pretend it was enough.
The question isn’t whether you can prove that you understand your thinking.
It’s what might help you now.
In working together, we can draw on CBT, mindfulness, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and transformative approaches. I’ll explain what we’re exploring and why, and we’ll review whether it is helping.
You don’t need to work this out alone
My role isn’t to tell you that it is “only thinking” until you agree.
It is to listen, help you notice what you may not have seen, and connect our conversations with the life you want to live.
You can bring your understanding, your doubts and the parts that still don’t make sense. We can start there.
I offer private therapy in Ferndown, Dorset, and online across the UK.
Meet me on Zoom, or request a phone call. No obligation to continue.